The Three Smith Brothers From Ireland
THE THREE SMITH BROTHERS FROM IRELAND My great great grandfather was George Smith who was born in 1825 in Ireland. The first record I have of him is an 1850 census entry where I found him in the town of Granby in Oswego County New York. He married another Irish immigrant also named Smith with the first name of Mary shortly after that as my great grand- father was born in Oct. 1851. George owned a farm in Granby but in 1860 he sold that one and purchased another larger farm a few miles west in the town of Hannibal also in Oswego County. He died in the spring of 1869 leaving his widow and five children ages 1 thru 17. I have known the above information for about ten years shortly after I began my genealogical research. I had not learned anything further on the Smith family until recently. In February 1983 I received a letter from a cousin in Loveland Colo. who was collecting Smith family information in preparation for a Smith Family reunion to be held in Colorado during the summer. 1983 was the 100th anniversary of the settlement of the Frank Smith family from New York State to a remote ranch in Summit County Colo. I sent some of my information to my cousin but as I had already planned an Easter trip to Colorado to see my father we agreed to get together and compare notes as she had a wealth of information from family and public sources in Colo. while my information was mainly from public and printed sources here in New York State. This visit proved to be very productive as the wife of one of Frank Smiths grandsons had found some notes on family history which had been written by a grandson of George Smith a number of years ago and sent to Frank Smiths daughter Olive. This information led to contacts with descendants of James and Samuel Smith as it disclosed that there were three brothers all of whom lived in Oswego County N.Y. These descendants also had further information on the origin and circumstances of the immigration from Ireland of the three Smith brothers, James, George and Samuel. Information gathered to date indicates that James, George and Samuel were the sons of John Smith and Jane Little. There is good reason to believe that the place in Ireland that they came from may be the small town of Plumb Bridge in County Tyrone which is located about 20 miles due south of Londonderry. James was born in August [Page 2] 1823, George in 1825 and Samuel in June 1828. After the death of their mother, which was probably at the time of Samuels birth or shortly thereafter, the children went to live with an Aunt who was the wife of Andrew Murphy. A few years later, probably in the 1830s the Andrew Murphys came to Canada bringing the Smith brothers. Either their father John Smith had died or perhaps, as one account relates, he had remarried and his new wife chose not to have the responsibility of raising the three sons. It appears that John Smith may have helped Andrew Murphy emigrate to America if he would take the three boys with him and raise them. It is not known at this time if John Smith had any other children or if Andrew Murphy and the Aunt had children of their own. It is believed that the Murphys went to the Brockville Ontario area in Canada. We know that James Smith was married in Brockville in Oct. 1846 and that his two oldest sons were born there in 1847 and 1849. When the 1850 census was taken James and George were living in the same household in the town of Granby in Oswego County N.Y. Family accounts indicate that Andrew Murphy with Samuel were also in New York State in the 1840s as Samuel related working as a tow horse driver along the canals as a young teenager. The earliest record of Samuel Smith found to date is a census entry for 1860 where he is in Palmyra, Wayne County N.Y, married and living with his in-laws. James Blaine Smith was born in Ireland in August 1823 and is the oldest of the three brothers that we have information on. The earliest record we have of James is his marriage in Brockville Ontario on 7 October 1846 to Eliza Mason. The marriage was performed by Conrad Van Duesen, a minister in the Wesleyen Methodist Church in Brockville. A son George was born in 1847 and another son Richard James was born 17 arch 1849, both in Brockville. When the 1850 census was taken James was living in the town of Granby in Oswego County New York. He remained a resident of this area the rest of his life. He had a farm in Granby but later owned a canal boat and operated a meat market in Fulton. He also had a real estate business. He was a devoted member of the Methodist Church. He owned a cottage at Thousand Island Park NY on Wellesey Island on the St. Lawrence River and ran a meat market there. This Park was founded as a Methodist Church operation. James died there on June 30 1912. [Page 3] James Smiths wife Eliza died in June 1894 and he remarried to Delia Webb in Dec 1895. Information that he gave at that time to obtain his marriage license furnishes us with the names of his parents, John Smith and Jane Little. James is buried in Mt. Adnah cemetery in Fulton along with his two wives. James and Eliza had three sons and one daughter. 1) George Smith the eldest of James was born in Canada in 1847. He was married to Sara DeEtt Bogart and was living in Junction City Kansas when his mother died in 1895. He was found in Junction City in the 1900 census which indicates he was employed as a salesman. He probably died before the death of his father as he was not listed as a survivor. He had a daughter Clara Josephine who was born in 1878 in New York State and who was living in Omaha Nebraska at one time. 2) Richard James Smith was born on 17 March 1849 in Brockville Ontario. He became a blacksmith and in the late 1870s came to Rochester New York where he owned his own shop. From 1891 on he was listed in the Rochester City Directories as a carriage manufacturer. He was married to Hattie M. Hodgson and they were the parents of three children. The oldest, Ruby, died young and there were two sons, Clifford and Charles. Richard died in Rochester on December 11 1916 and is buried in Mount Hope Cemetery. A granddaughter of his has been contacted and she has furnished much of this information on the James Smith Family. 3) Emma Smith was born September 23 1851 in Fulton. She married John Robinson who operated a grocery store in Fulton. He died in 1887 leaving her with two small children, Jennie and James. She continued to live in Fulton until her son James died In 1921 when she went to live with her daughter in Oklahoma. She died in Frederick Oklahoma in 1946. 4) Charles Watson Smith was born on September 29 1859 in Fulton New York. He was married to Kitty and lived in Kansas when their two daughters were born. In 1891 he moved to Kingfisher, Oklahoma where he was a lawyer and operated a real estate business. The daughters were Ruby born in June 1886 and Mildred born in May 1889. Charles died July 2 1947 in Kingfisher, Oklahoma. [Page 4] George Smith was born in December 1825. The first record that has been found is his listing in the 1850 census where we find him living with his brother James in the town of Granby, Oswego County. He married shortly after that census to Mary Smith, also from Ireland. The 1855 census indicates that he had been living in Oswego County for ten years. In 1859 he sold his farm in Granby and bought another a few miles west in town of Hannibal, also in Oswego County. George died on April 24 1869, leaving his wife and five children ages 1 to 17. He is buried in the Hannibal Center Cemetery with his wife and two of his daughters. 1) Frank (John Francis) Smith the oldest of George and Mary Smith was born in October 1851. He preferred to use his middle name and was known as Frank John in Colorado. He stayed on the family farm after his father died. He married Elizabeth Clive Sanders, a grand daughter of one of Hannibals earliest settlers on Nov 7 1878. Two children were born in Hannibal, Albert in 1880 who died as an infant and Lelah, in 1881. In 1883 Frank and his brother James moved his family to Colorado. Frank and James had been working in the mines for a year or two but he had found some good land to homestead and moved his family to Colo. Ten more children were born in Colo. Clive in 1884, Alice 1886, Walter 1888, Hugh 1889, Vernie 1891, James 1894, George 1895, Frank 1899, William 1902 and Earl 1907. Frank Smith died September 15 1929 and is buried in the Smith family cemetery near his ranch on the Blue River a little ways south of Heeney, Colo. 2) James Thomas Smith was born in Hannibal in March 1855. He went to Colo. with his brother and worked as a book-keeper and time- keeper in the mines. He started working for the state and by 1900 he was located in Denver as Deputy Commissioner of the State Bureau of Labor Statistics. He later operated an insurance business and a real estate office. In May 1923 he was elected a City Councilman and serve two years. He was married twice, both wives died of illness. He died on Jan 1 1939 leaving no survivors and is buried in Denver. 3) Lydia Isabelle Smith was born in 1857. In 1882 she married William Smith and they moved to North Dakota. 4) Sarah Etta Smith was born in 1859. She married Albert Gifford of Hannibal. She and her husband acquired the property owned by her uncle James Smith at Thousand Island Park shortly after 1900 and operated it as a resort for over 30 years with their son [Page 5] Bernie. Etta died in 1941 and is buried in Hannibal Center Cemetery Adjacent to her parents. 5) Eliza Jane (Lizzie) Smith was born April 11 1868. She became a school teacher. She died Oct. 15 1894 without marrying and left no survivors. She is also buried in Hannibal Center Cemetery. Samuel Smith was born in June 1828 in Ireland. The earliest record existing to date on Samuel is the 1860 census where he is listed living in Palmyra New York. He had been married shortly before to Mary Laughlin. He moved to Hannibal within a few years and by 1875 was living on the farm in Granby which he owned until his death. As a youngster he had worked on the Erie Canal which crossed New York State between Syracuse and Fulton and passed through the village of Palmyra. He went by the name of his uncle as a youth but took his family name of Smith when he became an adult. One of his grandsons who is still living in North Dakota has been the source of considerable information on Samuel. Samuel died while visiting his sons in North Dakota in 1903 (see obit.) and was sent back to New York State for burial. 1) William Smith was born in Palmyra N.Y on August 21 1860. After his marriage to Lydia Smith in 1882 in Hannibal, they went to North Dakota and took up a homestead. They had two sons, Roy, born in 1890 and Leland, born in 1898, who has shared a number of his memories of his grandfather. William died in Fargo, North Dakota on March 30 1952. His son Roy wrote a book of the Smith family experiences farming in North Dakota, which was printed in 1964 and has also been a valuable source of data. 2) George Lytle Smith was born in Palmyra N.Y about 1862. He also went to North Dakota in 1883 with his brother Will. In 1897 he married Mary Northrup. Shortly before WWI he moved to California where he died in 1955. He had three sons and one daughter, Lucille. One of his sons, Clifford, became a Presbyterian Minister and has furnished helpful family information in preparing this account. 3) Charles O. (C.O) was born in Hannibal in 1867. Around 1900 he also went to North Dakota where he remained for about thirty years before returning to New York State. He married Evelyn Lake and had no children. It is not known at this time when he died. 4) Jay Smith was born in Hannibal in 1871. He went to North Dakota about 1910. He married Sophia Goldberg and they had two sons, Gordon and Lester. Jay died in 1963. [Page 6] 5) John Smith was born in Granby in 1874. In 1900 he also moved to North Dakota. His first wife was Helen Greenwood who died in 1905 leaving a young son who was raised by his grandparents in Pennsylvania. John married Ida Nolting in 1908 and they had a son Willard and a daughter Marjorie. John died when the children were very young. 6) Hattie Smith was born in 1877 in Granby. She became a school teacher and taught school in Fulton and after 1911 when she went to North Dakota. Hattie never married and died in 1975. 7) Fred Smith was born in 1879 and was the only one of Samuels children to stay in New York State. His first wife was Emma Tilden and they had a son and a daughter. After his first wife died he married again and had several more children. Names of Freds children were Lawrence, Alice, Freda, June, Sammy, Freddie and Harold. It is not known when Fred Smith died. [Page 7] SMITH FAMILY INFORMATION Account sent by Rev. Clifford Smith Dec. 1983 My father had two brothers, James and George. My fathers mother died when he was born. An aunt took him. I thought it was his mothers sister, but now in trying to write this I believe it was his fathers sister. She was married to Andy Murphy. His name was recorded as Samuel Murphy. She died when my father was quite small and Andy Murphy came to Canada and brought my father. The two older brothers came to America. My father never had a chance to go to school. Andy Murphy was fond of the bottle. After staying in Canada a short time they came to Oswego. I think the canal was being built then. He worked on it and my father did too. How my father came to Palmyra I dont know. Andy Murphy married again after he came to Oswego they had two girls. They married. They used to come to our house. He and my grandfather worked in a brewery but neither one of them ever drank. He had a very poor upbringing and got no education. The canal was a pretty tough place in those times. He met my mother in Palmyra. I think she was eighteen when she was married. My grandmother had gotten her ready to go to Boston to school. I think to Mount Holyhoke as my grandmother had a cousin teaching there. She used one of the dresses her mother had made for her to go to school to be married in. Probably terribly disappointed her mother. My father was thirteen years older than my mother. They lived in Palmyra with my grandparents until after Will and George were born. My mother had never done any housework, just fine needlework. She had been taught by a French woman. My grandmother did beautiful work too. My father went to Hannibal and bought a small farm. My grandmother could not let her go on a farm alone so they sold their property there and went with her and stayed the rest of their lives. We all thought our grandmother was wonderful and I guess she was. She helped carry the load. I remember both so well. I guess I was about four when my grandfather died and about seven when my grandmother died. My grandfather was quite small and had snow white hair. My grandmother was quite tall and her hair only a little gray when she died. She was fine looking. Both like nice clothes. Your father had grandfathers silk hat. C.O one time when he was [Page 8] home wanted grandfathers ebony cane and mother gave it to him. He left it in his suitcase in the depot in St Paul and when he came back it was gone. Someone else admired it too. When father came to Oswego with Andy Murphy he got in touch with his brothers and went to them. Then he took his own name, Samuel Smith. So Samuel Smith and Samuel Murphy were the same person. My grandparents helped him in buying the farm he bought. I dont know who my Uncle James married. They had, I think, four children. Emma Smith, who married John Robinson was the youngest. Will went to school to her. She was a fire person. She had two children, James and Jennie. James died while in service and Jennie went to Kingfisher, Oklahoma to work for her Uncle Charlie who was a lawyer there. When James died, his mother went to Oklahoma to live with Jennie, who was married then. Jennie had, I think, three children. Uncle James family were strong Methodists and Emma Robinson taught Sunday School until she was almost ninety. She got so deaf she had to stop. The family moved from Kingfisher to ----. George Smith married your mother Mary Smith, no relation. Two boys and three girls I think. Mother and grandmother had Will and George baptised by the old family minister named Eaton when they were in Palmyra and they took Charlie and Jay back there to be baptised by the same old minister. I dont know when John was baptised or Fred. I wasnt baptised until I was in high school and then it was in the Congregational Church in Fulton, when I joined the church. My mother and father never took their letters from the Palmyra Presbyterian Church. Letter written by emma Smith Robinson and obtained from her Grand Niece in 1983 I will try to tell you what I know. James Smith, your great grandfather.Born in the north of Ireland of Scotch Irish parents, his father and mother died and he was brought to Brockville Ontario, Canada when he was about eight years old. He married there and two children, George, Claras father and your grandfather Richard John were born there, before they moved to Fulton, New York where I and Charlie were born. Your grandfather was a farmer for many years then he bought a canal boat and shipped grain from Oswego to NY City for several years. Then he finished as superintendent at Thousand Island Park. You can be proud of your Smith ancestry for both your grandfather and your great grandfather were christian gentlemen. Though not rich in worldy treasures, they both had what was far better honesty, integrity, uprightness, all the homely virtues. Document transcribed by AlisdairMoran. Checked by CMcIvor.Close